ODIHR logo.

OSCE/ODIHR Electoral Recommendations Database

Home About Search Help Staff Login
Search criteria:
Page 1 Location: North Macedonia Year of election: 2021 - 2021 Election type: Local
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The legal framework should be comprehensibly revised to address all outstanding ODIHR recommendations and to eliminate the numerous existing gaps and inconsistencies. The parliament should undertake this revision well before the next elections, following an open and inclusive consultation process in which the proposals by all stakeholders are given meaningful consideration.
Recommendation # in final report: 1
Type of recommendation: Priority
Thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Legal Framework and Electoral System
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
Continued vigorous efforts should be made by the authorities to counter any form of pressure on voters and on public and private-sector employees, including buying of votes. In line with existing legislation, reports of pressure and vote buying should be thoroughly investigated and prosecuted, with protection for those who reported. Public institutions should be proactive in informing public and state employees of independent mechanisms where they can report pressure in relation with elections, and senior state officials should issue clear public statements and written instructions that such actions will not be tolerated and that no citizen should fear any negative consequences as a result of supporting or not supporting any candidate or party.
Recommendation # in final report: 2
Type of recommendation: Priority
Thematic area: Campaign
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Partially
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Campaign
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To ensure the operational independence and efficiency of the State Election Commission, the authorities should guarantee that it receives an adequate and timely budget allocation. The capacities of the Commission’s personnel should match the responsibilities vested in the Commission under the Electoral Code, with essential staff employed on a permanent basis.
Recommendation # in final report: 3
Type of recommendation: Priority
Thematic area: Election Administration
Type of change required: Sub-legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Election Administration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
As previously recommended, the legal framework should be harmonized with international standards by removing all restrictions on electoral rights on the basis of intellectual or psychosocial disability.
Recommendation # in final report: 4
Type of recommendation: Priority
Thematic area: Voter Registration
Secondary thematic area: Participation of Persons with Disabilities
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Voter Registration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The accuracy of the voter register should be reinforced through systematic and electronic data updates, most notably for deaths and name changes, and the implementation of a co-ordinated nationwide system for the standardization of addresses.
Recommendation # in final report: 5
Type of recommendation: Priority
Thematic area: Voter Registration
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Voter Registration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To enhance transparency, the Electoral Code should require comprehensive disclosure of all types of campaign income, as well as expenditures by contestants, several days before election day. Campaign finance reports should include a breakdown of expenditures by constituency, and the deadline for submitting final reports should be shortened to reflect international good practice. In line with a prior recommendation, a mechanism for electronic submission of financial reports could be established.
Recommendation # in final report: 6
Type of recommendation: Priority
Thematic area: Campaign Finance
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Campaign Finance
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
Provisions regulating the public broadcaster’s newscasts during the campaign period should be revised, with a view to allow for editorial freedom and ensure equitable access and news coverage of smaller parties and independent candidates. Further reforms should aim at strengthening the quality of content produced by the public broadcaster, including investigative and analytical journalism.
Recommendation # in final report: 7
Type of recommendation: Priority
Thematic area: Media
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Media
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
Regulations on paid political advertisement in the media should be reconsidered, in order to allow unimpeded access to the media based on reasonable and objective criteria. A clear mechanism for dividing the budget among smaller parties and independent candidates should be established. The official decision on budget allocation for campaign advertisement in the media should be published in a timely manner.
Recommendation # in final report: 8
Type of recommendation: Priority
Thematic area: Media
Secondary thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Media
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The legal standing to file complaints should be extended to voters and citizen observers. To allow adequate time for the filing and handling of complaints, deadlines could be brought in line with international good practice.
Recommendation # in final report: 9
Type of recommendation: Priority
Thematic area: Election Dispute Resolution (EDR)
Secondary thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Complaints and Appeals
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The law should stipulate a clear timeframe for the holding of repeat elections in cases where the turnout requirement was not met in the first round of a mayoral election. To reduce the risk of failed elections, the voter turnout requirement for repeat elections could be reconsidered.
Recommendation # in final report: 10
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Legal Framework
Secondary thematic area: Electoral System
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Fully
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Legal Framework and Electoral System
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To enhance transparency and public confidence in their work, the State Election Commission and Municipal Election Commissions should publish all relevant documentation, such as budget, procurement plan, as well as all regulations and decisions in a consistent and timely manner.
Recommendation # in final report: 11
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Administration
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Partially
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Election Administration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The authorities should ensure adequate and timely financial and operational support to Municipal Election Commissions well ahead of election day. Communication and instructions from the State Election Commission to lower-level election bodies should be complete and timely, in order to ensure due co-ordination and unified implementation of procedures.
Recommendation # in final report: 12
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Administration
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Election Administration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
As previously recommended, the database of state and public employees used for the selection of election officials should be updated, in order to ensure a smooth and efficient selection process. The pool of institutions from which employees are called to serve on election bodies could be revised.
Recommendation # in final report: 13
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Administration
Type of change required: Sub-legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Election Administration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
In a coordinated effort, state and local authorities as well as other actors involved in the election process should undertake further measures to ensure independent access of persons with various types of disabilities to the entire election process.
Recommendation # in final report: 14
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Participation of Persons with Disabilities
Secondary thematic area: Election Administration
Type of change required: Sub-legal
Status of implementation: Partially
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Election Administration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The regulatory framework for voter registration procedures should be consolidated and harmonized to eliminate inconsistencies.
Recommendation # in final report: 15
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Voter Registration
Secondary thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Voter Registration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The authorities should take the appropriate measures necessary to ensure that all eligible voters are included in the voter register and the voter lists. The Electoral Code should be amended accordingly, including by removing restrictions based on expired identification documents, and by clarifying procedures for the inclusion in voter lists of persons who turn 18 between rounds.
Recommendation # in final report: 16
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Voter Registration
Secondary thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Partially
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Voter Registration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To ensure meaningful access to and transparency of the voter register and voter lists, the SEC should publish voter registration data disaggregated by polling station, periodically and before and after each election, while limiting the type of voters’ personal data made publicly available and introducing technical safeguards to prevent its unauthorized processing.
Recommendation # in final report: 17
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Voter Registration
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Fully
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Voter Registration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To ensure integrity and public confidence in the election process, the use of new technologies, including biometric identification devices, should be introduced after sufficient time and with detailed provisions to ensure adequate testing and for all stakeholders to be acquainted with the operation of such equipment.
Recommendation # in final report: 18
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Voter Registration
Secondary thematic area: Information and Communication Technologies (ICT)
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Partially
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Voter Registration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To ensure equal opportunities in the right to stand for all candidates, the required number of supporting signatures for independent candidates should be proportional to the actual number of registered voters per constituency. Consideration could be given to standardizing them at up to one per cent of registered voters, in line with international good practice.
Recommendation # in final report: 19
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Candidate Registration
Secondary thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Partially
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Candidate Registration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The legal framework should be amended to provide for possibilities for independent councillor candidates to contest an election individually.
Recommendation # in final report: 20
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Candidate Registration
Secondary thematic area: Electoral System
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Candidate Registration
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
In line with the principle of equality of opportunity, campaign rules should be revised to provide for more equitable access to the media and allocation of spaces for posters and billboards for small parties and independent candidates.
Recommendation # in final report: 21
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Campaign
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Campaign
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
Political parties and relevant state and public institutions should take further steps to encourage the participation of women in the electoral process and in political decision-making.
Recommendation # in final report: 22
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Participation of Women
Secondary thematic area: Campaign
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Campaign
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The legal framework for campaigning should be further amended to include clear rules for the participation of public officials, including on social networks.
Recommendation # in final report: 23
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Campaign
Secondary thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Campaign
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The legal framework for campaign finance should be revised to address existing gaps, including those concerning the amount of bank loans and the possibility to donate after elections, as well as third-party financing. To prevent undue influence by private donors and potential political corruption, donation and expenditure limits for local elections could be aligned so that a contestant’s campaign fund is not sourced from a single donation.
Recommendation # in final report: 24
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Campaign Finance
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Campaign Finance
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The agencies responsible for campaign finance oversight should conduct an effective scrutiny of campaign income and spending throughout the electoral process and should give proper and timely consideration to all reports and complaints concerning alleged irregularities.
Recommendation # in final report: 25
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Campaign Finance
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Campaign Finance
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
National broadcasters should endeavour to make their programmes accessible for persons with sensory impairments. Consideration could be given to amend the Electoral Code in order to provide clearer and more specific guidance on transmitting accessible information to the electorate.
Recommendation # in final report: 26
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Media
Secondary thematic area: Participation of Persons with Disabilities
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Mostly
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Media
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
The legal requirement on daily reporting by the media regulator to the election administration could be replaced by ad hoc reports addressing specific election-related concerns.
Recommendation # in final report: 27
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Media
Secondary thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Media
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To ensure effective remedy, the law should provide for timely judicial review of all election-related administrative decisions, including all State Election Commission regulations.
Recommendation # in final report: 28
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Dispute Resolution (EDR)
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Partially
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Complaints and Appeals
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
Rules on the admissibility of complaints should establish reasonable requirements, and the scope of admissible evidence should not be unduly limited. Decisions of the election administration should be reasoned, ensuring effective examination of the merits of all complaints.
Recommendation # in final report: 29
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Dispute Resolution (EDR)
Secondary thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Complaints and Appeals
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To increase transparency and ensure due process, the right to a public hearing involving both parties should be protected at both courts and election commissions.
Recommendation # in final report: 30
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Dispute Resolution (EDR)
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Fully
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Complaints and Appeals
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
Consideration could be given to strengthening the Municipal Election Commissions’ capacity and relevant procedures for handling complaints. The electronic system for filing and tracking complaints could be upgraded to provide timely updates of submitted complaints and increase transparency.
Recommendation # in final report: 31
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Dispute Resolution (EDR)
Secondary thematic area: Election Administration
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Complaints and Appeals
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
Election administration bodies at all levels should ensure unimpeded access of all accredited observers to the entire election process. To enhance transparency, the election administration should keep records of all observers and contestants’ representatives accredited to observe, make these available to the public in a timely manner and provide those accredited with proper identification, clearly indicating their names and affiliation.
Recommendation # in final report: 32
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Citizen and International Observation
Secondary thematic area: Election Administration
Type of change required: Sub-legal
Status of implementation: Mostly
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Citizen and International Observers
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To enhance the integrity of and trust in the voting process, the authorities should undertake comprehensive efforts to improve the quality of databases used for voter identification on election day and the functionality of the biometric voter identification system.
Recommendation # in final report: 33
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Day
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Partially
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Election Day
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To enhance the credibility and ensure the integrity of the biometric voter identification system, the State Election Commission should publish the number of voters who were identified by the equipment, per constituency and polling station, as part of the announcement of preliminary results.
Recommendation # in final report: 34
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Day
Secondary thematic area: Voter Registration
Type of change required: Practice
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Election Day
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
As previously recommended, consideration should be given to clarifying the rules to preserve the validity of ballots on which the voters’ will is clearly expressed. Consideration should also be given to allowing for the replacement of accidentally spoilt ballots.
Recommendation # in final report: 35
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Day
Secondary thematic area: Legal Framework
Type of change required: Legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Election Day
North Macedonia 2021 EOM Local elections
To ensure consistency and transparency in the results tabulation process, clear procedures for rectifying errors and discrepancies in result protocols should be established, including criteria for the recounts of ballots. All relevant data collected during election day, including the number of voters added to the voter lists, should be published by the SEC in a timely manner.
Recommendation # in final report: 36
Type of recommendation: Other
Thematic area: Election Day
Type of change required: Sub-legal
Status of implementation: Not implemented
Year of assessment: 2025
Final report heading: Election Day

Contact

Email: office@odihr.pl
Tel: +48 22 520 06 00

OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights

Miodowa 10
00-251 Warsaw, Poland